In the Lamar Hunt Cup clash on April 16, FC Naples faced Tampa Bay Rowdies, enduring ten rounds of penalty kicks before falling 9-8 to the established Rowdies. FC Naples showed resilience throughout the match, with goalkeeper Edward Delgado making key saves, but ultimately lost when Julian Cisneros hit the crossbar in the shootout.
Despite the loss, FC Naples had previously secured wins against Sarasota Paradise and Little Rock Rangers in the Lamar Hunt Cup. The team also holds a strong position in the USL League One standings, with a 4-0-2 record. FC Naples' inaugural season has seen them perform well, with a dedicated fan base supporting them at home games, including the clash against the Rowdies at the Paradise Coast Sports Complex. The team's coach, Matt Polland, commended the community's unwavering support and expressed confidence in their upcoming league matches.