Drafting a quarterback to sit for a year takes a different turn without Derek Carr in the picture. While Carr may still have a chance to return in 2025 pending medical advice, his recent actions suggest a reluctance to play, leaving uncertainty around his future with the Saints. Without Carr, the team faces the prospect of starting Spencer Rattler or a young rookie, potentially complicating the decision-making process.
The absence of Carr eliminates the clear starter scenario, putting pressure on Rattler or a rookie like Jalen Milroe or Jaxson Dart to step up. Milroe and Dart are seen as developmental prospects, with Rattler likely to take the starting role initially. However, if Rattler performs well, the team could face a dilemma on whether to stick with him or transition to the rookie drafted in 2025, adding complexity to the quarterback situation. A mid-round pick would offer a simpler resolution, with Rattler competing against a fourth-round selection, potentially avoiding a repeat battle in 2026 if quarterback performance falters this season.